Benjamin Netanyahu has been accused of attempting to consolidate power by attacking the Shin Bet leadership [Getty]
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said he will bring a vote to the government this week to dismiss the director of the Shin Bet internal security service, Ronen Bar.
Netanyahu said on Sunday he has had “ongoing distrust” with agency chief Ronen Bar, though the decision comes after an increasingly acrimonious dispute between the men focused largely on who bears responsibility for the 7 October, 2023, Hamas attack.
Bar, who was engaged in a public spat with Netanyahu in recent weeks over reforms to Shin Bet, has suggested there were political motives behind the premier’s decision to ask the government to dismiss him.
The New Arab takes a look at the impact this move could have, and what it means for Israel.
‘Unprecedented’
Attorney General Gali Baharav Miara – the executive’s top legal adviser who has often taken positions that clashed with those of Netanyahu’s government – said the move to sack Bar was “unprecedented” and its legality needed to be assessed.
Bar said it stemmed from his own refusal to meet Netanyahu’s demands for “personal loyalty”.
Israeli media reports say the Shin Bet was also investigating some of Netanyahu’s aides for allegedly receiving payments from Qatar, which hosts leaders of Hamas, even as the Gaza war raged.
Several opposition parties have already announced they will jointly petition the High Court against Bar’s dismissal, and the attorney general said in a letter to Netanyahu that he could not initiate the process “until the factual and legal foundation of your decision is fully clarified”.
Baharav Miara is herself under threat of a no-confidence motion submitted by Justice Minister Yariv Levin, who has spearheaded efforts to reform the judiciary and curb the court’s powers – a plan that sparked major protests before coming to an abrupt halt with Hamas’s 2023 attack.
Levin has accused Baharav Miara, a fierce defendant of the judiciary’s independence, of “inappropriate conduct” and cited “significant and prolonged disagreements between the government and the attorney general”.
The proceeding against the two figures promises to be lengthy, risking a repeat of the 2023 protest movement that was one of the most significant in Israel’s history and had deeply fractured the country.
‘Blow to national security’
The Kaplan Force, a liberal umbrella organisation which led the fight against judicial reform, on Monday, announced rallies in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv this week to protest the dismissal of the Shin Bet head.
The move to sack Bar, who has been involved in negotiations over the fragile ceasefire in Gaza, comes at a crucial time for the talks.
The truce has largely held since January 19 despite an impasse in efforts to extend it.
Since the Gaza war began, Netanyahu has dismissed his defence minister, Yoav Gallant, while several senior military officials have resigned including army chief Herzi Halevi.
Benny Gantz, an opposition figure who once served as defence minister under Netanyahu, said on X that “the dismissal of the head of the Shin Bet is a direct blow to national security and a dismantling of unity within Israeli society, driven by political and personal considerations.”
Former Supreme Court president Dorit Beinisch told Kan public radio that Netanyahu was leading “processes that are dangerous for society”.
“We need to wake up, and to wake up in time,” she said.
Power grab
For Netanyahu’s allies, the move against Bar falls within the normal rights of the head of government.
“In what normal country is a special reason even needed to remove the head of an intelligence organisation who is personally responsible for a massive intelligence failure that led to the greatest disaster in the history of Israel?” far-right Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich wrote on Telegram.
Nahum Barnea, columnist for the daily Yedioth Ahronoth, warned of the dangers stemming from the clash between Netanyahu and Bar.
“A prime minister who has lost his brakes will rule as he sees fit, and his failed government will follow in his wake,” he wrote.
“It is gradually inching us closer to a form of civil war… in which there is no trust and a refusal to obey in security organisations”.
For Amir Tibon, writing for the left-wing daily Haaretz, “Israeli democracy is now in grave danger”.
“It’s up to Israelis to decide if they’ll accept Netanyahu’s hostile power-grab – and how far they will go to stop it”.
