Canada’s Liberal leader and Prime Minister-elect Mark Carney on March 9. Photo by Dave Chan/AFP via Getty Images
By Jacob Kornbluh
April 28, 2025
This story was originally published on March 9 and has since been updated throughout.
Mark Carney, the current prime minister and recently elected leader of Canada’s Liberal Party, has vowed to protect Canadian Jews amid rising antisemitism, but his stance on Israel has drawn scrutiny. Carney leads Conservative Party candidate Pierre Poilievre in the latest polls, as Canadians vote in today’s election.
A former banker, Carney had never held elected office until he won a four-person race in March, with 85.9% of the vote, to lead the ruling party after Justin Trudeau announced his departure in January, stepping down after nine years in office amid internal party tensions.
Carney, 60, took office amid growing trade tensions between Canada and the U.S., and has largely continued Trudeau’s approach to rising antisemitism and Israel. Poilievre, who hitchhiked through Israel in his youth and has described Canadian Jews as “the true Indigenous people,” had a commanding lead in the polls initially but his party’s advantage narrowed in recent weeks due to a nationalist backlash against President Donald Trump’s tariffs on Canadian imports.
What would Carney’s leadership mean for Jews and Israel?
Canada’s 335,000 Jews have faced a surge in antisemitism, including firebombs and gunshots at synagogues since the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel and protests over the war in Gaza. Trudeau criticized Israel’s military response in Gaza, backed a United Nations resolution against Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank, and said Canada would enforce the International Criminal Court’s arrest warrant for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Jewish leaders who welcomed Trudeau’s exit said they were skeptical that his successor will improve relations. So far, they have not been satisfied and some are endorsing Poilievre.
Carney, who met with Netanyahu on a 2012 visit to Israel, balanced his support for Israel’s right to self-defense and the removal of Hamas as Gaza’s governing authority with a focus on humanitarian concerns for Palestinians. Earlier this year, he called Trump’s plan to relocate millions of Palestinians from Gaza “deeply disturbing” and suggested it would violate international law.
But his messaging has been mixed. During a recent debate, Carney raised eyebrows when he mistakenly said that he “was in agreement with Hamas” while answering a question about postwar governance. His chief rival at the time, Chrystia Freeland, interjected, saying that the party did not support Hamas. Carney quickly corrected his French, clarifying that he meant supporting the establishment of an independent Palestinian state without involvement from the terrorist group.
“I support the hard work of reaching a two-state solution, with a viable and free Palestinian state living side by side in peace and security with the state of Israel,” Carney posted on social media in February.
Earlier this month, Carney appeared to agree with a heckler who said Israel was committing genocide, citing Canada’s arms embargo against Israel. Netanyahu called Carney’s response “irresponsible.”
Carney’s critics say he hasn’t been vocal enough. Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East gave Carney a “D+” on Palestinian rights, citing his lack of public statements. Meanwhile, Jeremy Levi, the Conservative mayor of Hampstead, a suburb of Montreal, blasted Carney for not mentioning “Israel” or “antisemitism” in recent social media posts. “Silence speaks volumes, and his silence is deafening,” Levi wrote on Instagram.
Carney was among 50 leaders and clergy who signed an open letter urging the government to enforce the law at pro-Palestinian protests and strengthen awareness about what constitutes hate speech.
Following Oct. 7, Carney quoted Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel, and said: “I learned the perils of language and those of silence. I learned that in extreme situations where human lives and dignity are at stake, neutrality is a sin.” Attending a Holocaust Remembrance Day commemoration in January, he said that in response to rising antisemitism, “‘Never Again’ is more than a phrase — it must be a promise.”
Carney recently condemned the defacing of a Montreal synagogue with a swastika during Shabbat. “It has to stop,” he wrote on X. “As Canadian leaders, we need to say firmly and loudly that the Jewish community has the right to feel safe in Canada.”
I hope you appreciated this article. Before you go, I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward.
Now more than ever, American Jews need independent news they can trust, with reporting driven by truth, not ideology. We serve you, not any ideological agenda.
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back, the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S. on the impact of the war, rising antisemitism and polarized discourse.
This is a great time to support independent Jewish journalism you rely on. Make a gift today!
— Rachel Fishman Feddersen, Publisher and CEO
